Can You Have More Than One Attachment Style? Why Attachment Strategies Tell a Truer Story

Yes, most people show traits of more than one attachment style. The four familiar categories (secure, anxious, avoidant, and disorganized) are broad summaries, and research on how attachment is actually distributed finds that people vary along a spectrum rather than falling neatly into types. A more accurate way to describe what’s going on is that each person uses their own unique mix of attachment strategies, some leaning anxious, some leaning avoidant, shaped by their particular history and the particular relationship they’re in.

One of the questions I hear most often goes something like this: “I’m pretty sure I have anxious attachment. Everything I read about it resonates so much. But then I notice myself shutting down, or pushing someone away when they get close. Isn’t that avoidant? So does that mean I’m disorganized?”

I love this question, because it points at something real. The four attachment styles are a useful, simple way to explain attachment to a lot of people at once. They give us language. They help things click. But the reality underneath them is much more nuanced, much more personal, and honestly, much more interesting.

Free mini-course

Free 6-Week Attachment Reparenting Course

Reparent Yourself’s free 6-week attachment reparenting course gives you an experiential introduction to the Ideal Parent Figures method of attachment healing, so you can understand what one of the most reliable paths to earned security actually feels like in practice.

Start the free course

What Is an Attachment Style?

Definition

Attachment Style

An attachment style is a broad category describing how a person tends to approach closeness, dependence, and separation in relationships. The four most common labels are secure, anxious (or anxious-preoccupied), avoidant (or dismissing), and disorganized (sometimes called fearful-avoidant). They summarize typical patterns rather than fully describing any single person.

An attachment style is a shorthand for the overall shape of how someone relates to closeness and connection. It’s a summary of tendencies, not a diagnosis and not a fixed identity.

The categories came out of decades of research. Mary Ainsworth’s infant studies gave us the original secure, avoidant, and ambivalent patterns. Mary Main and Judith Solomon later added disorganized, for babies whose behavior didn’t fit any of the three. Then in the late 1980s, Cindy Hazan and Phillip Shaver brought the categories into adult romantic relationships, and Kim Bartholomew expanded them to four adult prototypes. Dr. Daniel P. Brown and Dr. David Elliott trace this whole lineage in detail in Attachment Disturbances in Adults, which is still the book I return to more than any other.

And these categories really are useful. When someone reads about anxious attachment for the first time and feels that jolt of recognition (“oh, that’s me”), something important happens. A lifetime of confusing experiences suddenly has a shape. There’s relief in that. There’s hope in that.

The trouble starts when the shape becomes a box.


Where the Four Boxes Start to Break Down

The four-category model breaks down because real people rarely fit only one category. Most show a blend of anxious and avoidant tendencies that shift over time, across relationships, and across situations, and the research on adult attachment has moved away from types for exactly this reason.

This isn’t a new discovery. Even Kim Bartholomew, who created the four-category model most people know today, noticed it right away. Brown and Elliott quote her 1991 study with Leonard Horowitz, in which the researchers reported that “none of the subjects in this project uniquely fit any one attachment prototype.” Most people showed a mix of tendencies, and many showed elements of two, three, or occasionally all four styles. The researchers noted that a lot of individual variation got lost when those ratings were collapsed into a single category.

Since then, the evidence has kept pointing the same direction:

  • Attachment is dimensional, not categorical. A large analysis by Fraley, Hudson, Heffernan, and Segal (2015) tested whether adult attachment styles behave like distinct types or like continuous dimensions, and the results favored dimensions. Earlier work by Fraley and Spieker (2003) found the same pattern in infant behavior, and a large pooled analysis of Adult Attachment Interviews found dismissing, preoccupied, and unresolved states of mind were better described as continuous than categorical.
  • Anxiety and avoidance are two separate dials. As Brown and Elliott describe, a major factor analysis by Brennan, Clark, and Shaver (1998) found that adult romantic attachment comes down to two dimensions: attachment anxiety and attachment avoidance. You can be high on one, moderate on the other, and low on neither.
  • You can relate differently to different people. Fraley and colleagues (2011) found that people develop relationship-specific attachment patterns, holding distinct working models with a partner, a parent, and a close friend.

So when you notice yourself acting anxious with your partner, avoidant with your mom, and pretty secure with your best friend, nothing has gone wrong with you. That’s what attachment looks like in a real human being.


Am I Anxious or Avoidant? Does That Mean I’m Disorganized?

You’re probably not one or the other. Almost everyone uses some anxious strategies in certain situations and some avoidant strategies in others, and having both does not mean you have disorganized attachment. Disorganized attachment isn’t defined by mixing anxious and avoidant behavior. It’s defined by the level of fear in attachment, where closeness itself feels dangerous because a childhood caregiver was a source of fear as well as comfort.

A lot of sources say that if you’re both anxious and avoidant, you must be disorganized. I understand why that idea spreads. It’s tidy, and it seems to account for the mix. But it’s a deep, and I think dangerous, oversimplification of how attachment works. It can lead someone to believe their attachment is far more frightened and fragmented than it is, and it blurs what disorganized attachment actually involves for the people who do live with it.

Which strategies you lean toward isn’t fixed. It can shift with your mood, your state of mind, your level of stress, who you’re relating with, and what’s going on in that particular relationship. Research tracking couples over time has found that most people experience fluctuations in how secure they feel with a specific partner. You might lean anxious on a stressful week and avoidant when you’re exhausted and stretched thin. That’s not chaos. That’s a responsive human being.

To see why, it helps to know two terms from the researchers Mario Mikulincer and Phillip Shaver. In their model of attachment and emotion regulation, when reaching for comfort doesn’t reliably work, people develop secondary strategies. Hyperactivating strategies turn the volume up on attachment needs. Deactivating strategies turn it down.

Strategy Usually Linked To What It Can Look Like
Hyperactivating Anxious attachment Scanning for signs of withdrawal, seeking reassurance, replaying conversations, amplifying distress so it gets noticed, people pleasing
Deactivating Avoidant attachment Going numb, getting busy, minimizing needs, pulling away when someone gets close, “I’m fine, I don’t need anything”
Both, in a stable mix Most real people Mostly reaching, with some shutting down when overwhelmed (or the reverse). Each move still makes sense as a way of staying connected or staying safe
Collapse of strategy Disorganized attachment Moving toward and away from someone at the same time, freezing, confusion or dissociation around closeness, fear of the very person you want comfort from

Here’s the important distinction. Someone with mostly anxious attachment might text their partner five times, and then, after the fifth message goes unanswered, go cold and decide they don’t care anymore. That shutting down is a deactivating move. But it’s still organized. It has a logic: “reaching isn’t working, so I’ll protect myself by stopping.”

Disorganized attachment is different in kind, not just in amount. The difference is fear. As George Haas puts it in his teaching, it’s not only that someone with disorganized attachment is afraid of being abandoned or shamed. At the deepest level, they’re afraid of dying.

That level of fear usually has roots in a childhood that felt unsafe with the people who were supposed to provide safety. Brown and Elliott describe how Mary Main and Erik Hesse observed that parents of disorganized infants often showed both frightening and frightened behavior, and how later research found that a parent’s dissociation and unresolved trauma or loss were also strong predictors. The child faces what researchers called fear without solution: the person they need to run to for safety is also the person they need safety from. Sometimes it’s less obvious than that. A childhood can also be deeply confusing, say with one parent who’s highly anxious, another who’s highly avoidant, and trauma running through the household. Either way, the child never gets to develop one coherent strategy. What develops instead are contradictory ones.

And that history doesn’t just live in memory. Even if, as an adult, someone doesn’t consciously register closeness as physically dangerous, the body can hold onto that early sense of danger. So when intimacy deepens, the response might be freezing, going blank, feeling confused, or getting caught in an intense pull toward someone and push away from them at the same time.

The confusion between “mixed” and “disorganized” is understandable, and the line can get blurry. Brown and Elliott themselves describe people with disorganized attachment as showing a prominent mix of anxious-preoccupied and dismissing strategies. So mixing alone isn’t the marker. What sets disorganization apart is the fear tied to closeness itself, the sense of strategies breaking down rather than taking turns, and often signs of dissociation or unresolved trauma. If that description lands hard for you, it’s worth finding a therapist experienced with trauma and attachment, rather than trying to sort it out alone.


What Is an Attachment Strategy?

Definition

Attachment Strategy

An attachment strategy is a specific, learned way of trying to stay safe and connected in relationships, such as turning emotional signals up to get attention or turning them down to avoid rejection. Where an attachment style labels a person, an attachment strategy describes something a person does, in a particular context, for a particular reason.

An attachment strategy is something you do, not something you are. That shift in language sounds small, but it changes a lot.

“I am anxious” can start to feel like a sentence. A verdict. “I use some anxious strategies, especially when I’m afraid of being left” opens a door. It invites curiosity. Where did I learn that? What is it trying to do for me? What happens right before it kicks in?

Every one of these strategies made sense when it formed. If reaching loudly was the most reliable way to get a caregiver’s attention, a child learns to reach loudly. If expressing need got met with irritation, a child learns to need less. These aren’t flaws. They’re the best solutions a young nervous system could find for staying close to the people it depended on.

You’ll notice that people who know this field well tend to talk this way. George Haas, the founding teacher of Mettagroup, who brings together insight meditation and attachment work, has described his own challenging childhood as leaving him with a “fearful avoidant attachment strategy”. Strategy. Something learned, for good reason. Something that can keep unfolding.


What Is the Dynamic-Maturational Model of Attachment?

The Dynamic-Maturational Model (DMM) is a model of attachment developed by psychologist Patricia Crittenden that describes attachment in terms of self-protective strategies rather than fixed personality types. It keeps the familiar avoidant-leaning (A), balanced (B), and anxious-leaning (C) patterns, but breaks them into many sub-patterns and combinations that can shift with development, with different relationships, and with different levels of threat.

Crittenden was a student of Mary Ainsworth, and her model grew out of a simple but radical idea: attachment behavior is fundamentally about protecting yourself from danger and getting the protection you need. As Brown and Elliott summarize it, Crittenden sees maladaptive patterns as the result of repeated exposure to danger that went unprotected and uncomforted. The problem was never the child. It was the danger.

In the DMM:

  • Type A strategies lean on thinking and predictability, and tend to downplay feelings. These roughly correspond to avoidant patterns.
  • Type C strategies lean on feelings and tend to amplify them. These roughly correspond to anxious patterns.
  • Type B strategies balance both. The most integrated of these, which Crittenden calls B3, is described as using the widest range of strategies, each one when it’s appropriate.

That last point stopped me in my tracks the first time I read it. In this model, security isn’t the absence of anxious or avoidant moves. It’s flexible access to all of them. A secure person can reach out loudly when that’s what the moment calls for, and can step back and hold their own feelings when that’s what fits. What makes it secure is the freedom to choose.

The DMM also has a lot to say about the exact question I started with. Crittenden describes combined A/C strategies, where a person draws on both. According to Crittenden and Landini, as quoted by Brown and Elliott, a person might use one strategy with one parent and another with the other, or use C strategies for mild threats and A strategies for serious ones. Where Main’s model might call some of these mixes disorganized, Crittenden sees many of them as organized strategies in their own right.

So the person who’s anxious most of the time, and then goes cold when things feel really threatening? In the DMM, that’s a recognizable, coherent pattern, not a sign that something is scrambled.

I want to be fair about the limits here. The DMM is more granular, and it’s harder to learn. Assessment requires extensive training, and it doesn’t translate easily into a quick online quiz. A 2013 review by Landa and Duschinsky praised the model’s depth while also discussing concerns that have been raised about its evidence base and whether its list of strategies is complete. It’s less accessible for a general audience. But I think it’s probably closer to the truth of how people actually work.

Lens Associated With What It Offers
Four attachment styles Ainsworth, Main, Bartholomew Simple, memorable language that helps people recognize their patterns. Easily oversimplifies a mixed reality
Two dimensions Brennan, Shaver, Fraley Places you on a spectrum of anxiety and avoidance. Fits the research best, but says less about why or when
Attachment strategies (DMM) Patricia Crittenden Detailed map of specific self-protective strategies and how they combine. Harder to learn and to assess
Clusters of parts Parts work, Aletheia Treats each strategy as a part of you with its own history and intention. An experiential lens rather than a research measure

Attachment Styles as Clusters of Parts

The more I train in parts work, the more I’ve come to see attachment styles as common clusters of parts. There’s a familiar set of parts and protectors that, when we look at the whole ecosystem together, we tend to call anxious attachment. There’s another familiar set that we tend to call avoidant. And so on.

Take what we usually call anxious attachment. In one person it might include a part that scans faces for the slightest flicker of disapproval. A part that reaches, and reaches, and reaches. A part that criticizes them for being “too much.” A part that people pleases so nobody leaves. And, living right alongside all of those, maybe a part that goes numb when everything gets overwhelming, or a part that decides, after one too many disappointments, “fine, I don’t need anyone.”

That last part is a deactivating protector. It’s in there. It’s doing its job. And it doesn’t cancel out everything else.

Avoidant attachment works the same way. Someone might have a part that prizes independence, a part that gets very busy whenever feelings come up, a part that finds a partner’s needs a little suffocating. And often, under all of that, a young part that longs to be held and has learned to keep very still about it.

I’ve been training in Aletheia, a parts work and coaching approach developed by Steve March, who has been a coach since 2000. Steve talks about the Enneagram in a way that really shaped how I think about this. In a conversation on The Practical Enneagram podcast, he describes an Enneagram type’s fixation as a constellation of parts, and talks about using the Enneagram as a mirror rather than a map. People who share a type tend to share certain typical parts. That’s why the types are recognizable. But no human actually fits inside a box, and the box isn’t the point. The point is meeting the specific parts that are actually there.

To me, attachment styles work the same way. The labels name common trends. Your parts are your own.

And each of those parts is trying to support you. The scanning part is trying to keep you close to the people you love. The part that goes cold is trying to keep you from getting hurt again. Neither one is the enemy. They’re each holding a piece of your history, and each doing the best they know how.


Why the Labels Still Have a Place

None of this means the four attachment styles are useless. They’re a starting point, a doorway. The trouble only comes when we mistake the doorway for the whole house.

There’s a teaching in Tibetan Buddhism that I find helpful here: things like names and categories are useful designations, not solid things that exist on their own. You can use the word “anxious” the way you use the word “river.” It points at something real, and it’s helpful for getting around. But if you go looking for the fixed, permanent thing the word refers to, you won’t find it. You’ll find movement. Change. Process. Dr. Daniel P. Brown spent decades translating and teaching this tradition alongside his attachment research, and his book Pointing Out the Great Way maps the stages of Mahamudra meditation in remarkable detail. I don’t want to put words in his mouth about attachment labels specifically, but I do find it moving that the same person who helped systematize attachment work also spent his life pointing toward awareness that isn’t confined by any category at all.

There’s a practical point here too. Online attachment quizzes and in-depth interview assessments don’t measure quite the same thing. Brown and Elliott cite work by Crowell, Fraley, and Shaver showing that the average correlation between the Adult Attachment Interview and self-report attachment questionnaires is only about .15, which is quite weak. So if a quiz told you you’re anxious, take that as a useful clue, not a final word.


How Ideal Parent Figures and Aletheia Help With Attachment Styles

Ideal Parent Figures and Aletheia support attachment from two complementary angles. Ideal Parent Figures builds an overall felt sense of what secure attachment is like, through guided imagery of growing up with ideally attuned parent figures. Aletheia parts work helps you get to know the specific anxious and avoidant strategies that are unique to you, meeting each part with understanding rather than trying to make it go away.

In my work with clients through Reparent Yourself, these are the two approaches I lean on most, and they fit the way of seeing attachment I’ve been describing here. One speaks to the broad shape of your attachment. The other speaks to your particular mix of strategies.

Definition

Ideal Parent Figures (IPF)

Ideal Parent Figures is a guided imagery method developed by Dr. Daniel P. Brown and Dr. David Elliott. Guided by a facilitator, you imagine yourself as a young child being raised by parent figures who are ideally suited to you and your needs. Over time, these imagined relationships give your system a felt experience of secure attachment it can learn from.

Ideal Parent Figures: Feeling What Security Is Like

Ideal Parent Figures is the central practice in Brown and Elliott’s Three Pillars model, their overall approach, which pairs the imagery with practices for developing metacognition and collaborative ways of relating. The ideal parent figures aren’t your actual parents, and they aren’t a generic picture of perfect parents either. They’re figures your own imagination generates as being exactly right for you. They offer what Brown and Elliott describe as the core conditions for secure attachment: a felt sense of safety and protection, being seen and known, being soothed, being delighted in, and being supported in becoming your best self.

What I appreciate, given everything in this article, is that the imagery is tailored to the person. Someone who mostly uses anxious strategies might need ideal parent figures who are unmistakably consistent and present, who make it clear there’s no guesswork about whether they want to be there. Someone who mostly uses avoidant strategies might need figures who are warmly interested in their inner world without being intrusive. And because a skilled facilitator follows what’s actually happening for you, moment by moment, the ideal parents can meet whichever part shows up, whether that’s the part that reaches or the part that pulls away.

Sessions are usually recorded, so you can return to the imagery between sessions. That means much more time spent in the felt experience of being securely held than an hour a week would allow. Brown and Elliott report pilot outcome data in Attachment Disturbances in Adults showing substantial shifts toward secure attachment on the Adult Attachment Interview, though it’s worth knowing these were small pilot studies rather than large controlled trials.

Free mini-course

Free Intro to Ideal Parent Figures Course

Reparent Yourself’s free 6-week IPF course gives you an experiential introduction to Ideal Parent Figures, so you can understand what one of the most reliable paths to earned security actually feels like in practice.

Start the free course

Aletheia: Meeting Your Own Mix of Parts

Aletheia is the approach I mentioned earlier, developed by Steve March. Its parts work borrows some moves from Internal Family Systems but differs from it in important ways, and it doesn’t stop at parts. Aletheia works with four depths: parts, process (the felt sense in the body, underneath the parts), presence (qualities like courage, strength, compassion, and love that live beneath emotion and story), and nonduality.

At the depth of parts, when something comes up, say the part that scans for disapproval or the part that goes cold, the move isn’t to correct it or push it away. It’s to see it, name it, and love it exactly as it is, without needing it to be different. That’s what makes it such a natural fit for working with attachment strategies. The reaching part and the withdrawing part don’t have to fight over which one is “really you.” Both get met. Both get understood. And as they feel met, there’s often more access to that depth of presence underneath them.

How I Bring Them Together

With many clients, I start with Ideal Parent Figures for an extended stretch, often months or longer, to build a felt sense of what secure connection is like. That gives the overall tone, a roadmap for what being seen and supported actually feels like. Then, once that foundation feels steady, Aletheia parts work can help us get curious about the specific, idiosyncratic strategies that are unique to that person. Not to get rid of them. To understand them more deeply, appreciate how they’ve been trying to support you, and then imagine, feel, and play with new ways of being, so your system can gradually come to trust them.



Working With a Coach on Your Own Mix of Attachment Strategies

If you’ve been trying to figure out which box you belong in, you might find it a relief to set the question down. You don’t have to be one thing. You get to be the specific, complicated, beautiful person you actually are.

If you’d like support exploring your own mix of strategies, with Ideal Parent Figures, parts work, or both, you can book a free discovery call with Reparent Yourself. And if you want to get a feel for the Ideal Parent Figures method first, my free six-week intro course is a gentle place to start.


A Few Questions to Sit With

What would it be like to stop asking “which attachment style am I?” and start asking “which parts of me showed up today?”

Which strategies feel most familiar to you? And when do the less familiar ones appear?

What might those parts be trying to protect, and what might they be longing for?

It might feel good to sit with these. It might feel a little uncomfortable. Either way, that curiosity can be a pathway into knowing yourself more deeply.


Frequently Asked Questions About Attachment Styles vs Attachment Strategies

Can you be anxious and avoidant at the same time?

Yes. Research on adult attachment treats anxiety and avoidance as two separate dimensions rather than opposite ends of one scale, so a person can be moderately high on both. Many people mostly use anxious strategies, like seeking reassurance, and also use avoidant ones, like shutting down, when they feel overwhelmed or hurt. This mix is very common and doesn’t on its own mean anything is wrong.

Am I anxious or avoidant, and does having both mean I’m disorganized?

Most people aren’t purely one or the other. Almost everyone uses anxious strategies in some situations and avoidant strategies in others, and which one shows up can shift with stress, mood, and the relationship. Having both does not make you disorganized. Disorganized attachment is defined by the level of fear in attachment: closeness itself feels dangerous, usually because a childhood caregiver was a source of fear as well as comfort, and it often comes with freezing, confusion, or dissociation around intimacy.

What is the difference between an attachment style and an attachment strategy?

An attachment style is a broad category that summarizes a person’s overall pattern in relationships, such as anxious or avoidant. An attachment strategy is a specific, learned behavior for staying safe and connected, such as amplifying distress to get attention or minimizing needs to avoid rejection. Styles describe who someone tends to be; strategies describe what someone does, in a particular context, for a particular reason.

What is the Dynamic-Maturational Model of attachment?

The Dynamic-Maturational Model (DMM) is an approach to attachment developed by psychologist Patricia Crittenden. It describes attachment as a set of self-protective strategies rather than fixed types, using avoidant-leaning (A), balanced (B), and anxious-leaning (C) patterns with many sub-patterns and combinations. It also treats many mixed patterns that other models call disorganized as organized strategies that can shift with different people and different levels of threat.

Are online attachment style quizzes accurate?

They can be a useful starting point, but they capture only part of the picture. Self-report questionnaires measure how you see yourself in relationships, while interview-based assessments like the Adult Attachment Interview look at how you process attachment experiences, and the two correlate only weakly. A quiz result is best treated as a clue to explore rather than a final label.


This article draws on Attachment Disturbances in Adults by Dr. Daniel P. Brown and Dr. David Elliott, on Patricia Crittenden’s Dynamic-Maturational Model, on adult attachment research by Fraley, Shaver, Mikulincer, and colleagues, and on the Aletheia approach developed by Steve March. At Reparent Yourself, I work with people exploring their attachment patterns through Ideal Parent Figures and parts work.