A strong sense of self is a stable, felt knowing of who you are, a sense that you can have a real impact on your life and the people in it, and a warm feeling about who you are that doesn’t have to be earned. In Attachment Disturbances in Adults, Dr. Daniel P. Brown and Dr. David Elliott call these three qualities self-definition, self-agency, and self-esteem. They describe them as developing in that order, each growing out of the one before it, and all three can be cultivated in adulthood through the Ideal Parent Figure method.
I find these three ideas some of the most useful in all of Brown’s work. A lot of people come to me wanting to feel more secure in their relationships, and as we go, we discover that what’s underneath is a question about the self. Who am I when I’m not adapting to someone else? Do I actually like who I am? And can I go after the life I want without feeling like my worth is on the line every time?
Those three questions map pretty neatly onto self-definition, self-esteem, and self-agency. Let’s walk through each one, what it looks like when it’s still forming, and how Ideal Parent Figures can meet you in the imagination in a way that helps it grow.
Free mini-course
Free Intro to Ideal Parent Figures Course
Reparent Yourself’s free 6-week IPF course gives you an experiential introduction to Ideal Parent Figures, so you can understand what one of the most reliable paths to earned security actually feels like in practice.
What Does It Mean to Have a Strong Sense of Self?
Having a strong sense of self means you can feel who you are from the inside, and that feeling stays recognizably yours across moods, relationships, and seasons of life. You know what you think and value, you feel good about who you are without needing to earn it, and you trust that your choices make a difference. A weak sense of self is the opposite experience: an identity that shifts with whoever you’re with, worth that rises and falls with approval or achievement, and a feeling that life is happening to you.
In Brown and Elliott’s model, a secure sense of self is one of the main things secure attachment makes possible. Of the five conditions that support secure attachment (safety, attunement, soothing, expressed delight, and encouragement of play and exploration), that last one is what helps a child grow into their own unique person. Brown and Elliott describe parents who support a child’s inner and outer exploration without needing the child to turn out a certain way, so the child can discover who they are. When those conditions were missing or inconsistent in childhood, self-development often stays incomplete.
This is especially true for people with anxious attachment. Brown and Elliott point out that children of “involving” caregivers, parents who regularly pulled the child into their own needs, moods, and worries, learn to keep their attention on the other person’s state of mind. That other-focus makes a lot of sense as a childhood strategy. It helped the child stay connected. But it leaves less room for the self-observation and self-reflection that a sense of self is built from.
Research outside of Brown’s work points in the same direction. A 2009 study by Chia-huei Wu found that both attachment anxiety and avoidance were linked to lower self-concept clarity, with self-esteem helping to explain the connection. A 2022 study of more than 1,600 Hungarian adults found the same negative relationship between attachment insecurity and a clear sense of self. These are correlational studies, so they can’t tell us what causes what, but they line up well with what Brown describes.
What Is Self-Definition?
Self-definition is the felt sense of knowing who you are, along with the ability to recognize the specific qualities that make you you. It rests on what Brown calls a core sense of self: an experiential “selfness” you can evoke at any moment, which stays recognizably yours across different moods, relationships, and stages of life.
Definition
Self-Definition
Self-definition is a person’s recognition of particular qualities that are relatively consistent and stable aspects of their core self. It grows out of the core sense of self, the basic felt experience of “I am me,” and allows a person to hold their own views, interests, and values across different situations and relationships.
Brown gives a lovely example of this in the book. He describes being able to call up, at any moment, a general sense of “Dan” and a feeling of “Dan-ness.” (Brown’s first name was Daniel, and since mine is Dan too, I’ll admit this example has always made me smile.) On top of that general feeling, he can name specific qualities that belong to that Dan-ness. The general feeling is the core self. Being able to name the qualities is self-definition.
When I evoke my own sense of self, there’s something familiar there. Some days life is going great, and some days it’s really hard, but underneath both there’s this anchored sense of I am me. That’s what lets a person grow into their own person in the world, with their own beliefs, their own views, their own way of seeing things.
Psychologists have studied something closely related under the name self-concept clarity, defined by Jennifer Campbell and colleagues (1996) as the extent to which a person’s beliefs about themselves are clearly and confidently defined, internally consistent, and stable over time. It’s not identical to Brown’s concept, since Brown emphasizes the felt, experiential side, but it’s a helpful bridge between his work and the wider research literature.
When Self-Definition Is Still Forming
It’s completely normal for different sides of ourselves to come forward with different people. You might be more playful with one friend and more reflective with another. That’s flexibility, and it’s healthy.
What I’m talking about here is different. When self-definition hasn’t had the chance to fully develop, a person’s identity can shift dramatically depending on who they’re with. Their interests, opinions, and even values might reshape themselves around a new partner or friend group. Brown calls this defining the self “from the outside-in”: reading other people for cues about what’s expected and becoming that.
One of the most striking stories in the book is about a brilliant patient who could summarize twelve different theories of literary criticism flawlessly. When Brown asked what her view was, she couldn’t answer the question. She had taken in all these perspectives, but there wasn’t yet a self at the center to organize them around.
In relationships, this often shows up as enmeshment: a feeling of being completely merged with the other person, without a healthy sense of separateness. Brown also describes two quieter forms. In one, a person does have a sense of who they are, but keeps it hidden because it feels too fragile to be seen. In the other, the person attends so constantly to other people’s needs that their own self stays incomplete, and others experience them as a chronic caretaker. Brown notes that many very successful people live this way, having become extremely skilled at reading and meeting the needs of others.
How Ideal Parent Figures Support Self-Definition
In the Ideal Parent Figure method, you imagine yourself as a young child being raised by parent figures who are perfectly suited to you. For self-definition, Brown and Elliott describe parent figures who are curious about the uniqueness of this child, who have no agenda for who the child should become, and who see themselves as co-explorers of who this child is growing into.
Here’s one way a scene like this might unfold:
Inside an Ideal Parent Figures Scene
You’re about six, sitting on the kitchen floor with a pile of rocks you collected on a walk. Your ideal parent figures sit down with you. They don’t tell you which ones are the “good” rocks. Instead they ask which one is your favorite, and why. You hold up a gray one with a white stripe and tell them it looks like a road going around the world. They light up. “We love how you notice things like that. That’s so you.” Later, you tell them you don’t like the movie everyone at school loves, and they’re curious about that too. They want to know what you think. Not what they think, not what your friends think. You.
Over time, scenes like this help the imagined child, and the adult doing the practice, discover their own qualities from the inside rather than from other people’s expectations. Alongside Ideal Parent Figures, Brown and Elliott also describe a separate imagery practice that focuses on the self directly: imagining scenes where you’re most you, naming and amplifying the qualities that emerge, and carrying them into new contexts.
What Is Self-Agency?
Self-agency is the felt sense that you can have the impact you want on the world and on the people around you. It includes being able to set goals, break them down into steps that make sense, anticipate how things are likely to unfold, and move toward what you want. Brown describes it as the experience that the core self, with all its defining qualities, is effective.
Definition
Self-Agency
Self-agency is the internal sense of being an active, effective agent in the world, including in relationships. People with healthy self-agency experience themselves as helping to make things happen rather than having life simply happen to them, and they can organize goals and plans in a way that moves them toward what they want.
Brown traces self-agency back to early childhood. A toddler who gleefully knocks down a block tower every time a parent builds it is discovering that they can affect the world. A few months later, that same child starts building towers of their own. As language develops, the child learns they can affect people too, by asking, protesting, laughing, and reaching. Brown connects this to Albert Bandura’s concept of self-efficacy, the belief that you’re capable of carrying out the actions needed to reach a goal.
Self-agency in adult life can look like a lot of different things:
- A career shift. Deciding you want to become a nurse, a teacher, or a graphic designer, then researching programs, saving up, applying, and following through over a couple of years.
- A community project. Noticing your neighborhood has no shared green space and organizing neighbors, talking to the city, and starting a community garden.
- A creative goal. Wanting to record an album or write a book and building the daily habits and skills that make it real.
- A relationship need. Telling a partner, “I’m feeling a little insecure right now. Can you reassure me?” and trusting that asking can actually change something.
That last example matters a lot to me. Brown is clear that self-agency isn’t only about getting things done. Interpersonal self-agency, the sense that you can elicit the responses you need from others, is just as important. Brown notes that one sign of underdeveloped self-agency is chronically not getting what you want from relationships, with needs and wishes in intimacy going unmet.
When Self-Agency Is Still Forming
When self-agency hasn’t fully developed, life can feel like something that happens to you. Brown describes people who feel ineffective or helpless, who let others decide what they want, or who act impulsively because they haven’t had the chance to learn how to plan toward a goal. He also describes a different pattern: people who can make plans and set goals but find themselves holding back from acting on them, or pulled between competing goals that cancel each other out.
How Ideal Parent Figures Support Self-Agency
For self-agency, Brown and Elliott describe ideal parent figures who respond reliably when the child reaches out, who encourage the child’s ability to affect others, and who collaborate with the child on organizing goals and plans, helping them see the likely short- and long-term effects of their choices.
Here’s one way a scene like this might unfold:
Inside an Ideal Parent Figures Scene
You’re about nine, and you’ve decided you want to build a treehouse. Your ideal parent figures don’t take over, and they don’t brush it off. They get excited with you. “Okay, what do you think we need first?” Together you sketch a plan on a piece of paper. They ask what might go wrong, and you realize you’ll need to find out if the branch is strong enough. Some boards don’t fit and you get frustrated, and they help you settle and figure out the next step. When you ask your neighbor if you can borrow his ladder, and he says yes, your parent figures give you a look like, “See? You made that happen.” By the end of the summer there’s a lopsided little treehouse in the backyard, and you built it.
Notice the borrowed ladder. That moment of asking someone for something and having it work is interpersonal self-agency in miniature. With enough repetition, these scenes help build the expectation that your actions, and your requests, matter.
What Is Self-Esteem in Brown’s Model?
In Brown’s model, self-esteem is the linking of positive feeling with your sense of self. Drawing on psychoanalysts Joffe and Sandler (1966), Brown and Elliott define healthy self-esteem as the experience that when you evoke your sense of who you are, it comes with a warm, positive feeling, rather than with nothing at all or with negative feeling.
Definition
Self-Esteem (Brown & Elliott)
Self-esteem is the developmental linkage of positive emotional states to the self-representation. A person with healthy self-esteem feels good when they think of themselves, whether that sense of self comes up on its own or is deliberately called to mind.
I like this definition because it’s so experiential. Self-esteem isn’t a list of reasons you’re good enough. It’s what it feels like when you think of yourself. When you call up your sense of you, is there warmth there? A sense that you’re inherently valuable, that there’s nothing you need to do to earn people’s love, admiration, or respect?
That inherent sense of value is also what lets you feel that you bring something to your relationships. When it’s missing, people often put others on a pedestal. They might assume they aren’t good enough to be loved, fear being abandoned, or feel they need to work really, really hard to keep someone’s love because it doesn’t feel like it could come from simply being who they are.
Brown names three main childhood sources of healthy self-esteem. The first and most important is consistent expressed delight from attachment figures, what Heinz Kohut called “the gleam in the mother’s eye.” Brown is careful to say that this delight is in the child’s very being, not only in what the child does. The second is repeated experiences of mastery, the joy of discovering what you’re good at. The third, for older children, is structure and clear, consistent limits.
When Agency Gets Ahead of Esteem: Worth That Depends on Performance
This is one of the most common patterns I see, and Brown names it directly. When a child received warmth mainly in response to what they did, they may lean on achievement to make up for the delight in their being that wasn’t there. Brown writes that such children often grow up to be highly successful but unhappy people, because no amount of doing can stand in for feeling good in one’s being.
From the inside, this can feel like your worth depends on career success, on how well your relationships are going, on what you produce. There’s a constant seeking, as if something outside of you determines your value. It goes from the outside in rather than the inside out. And because worth is riding on it, performing well starts to feel like the condition for being loved. If you’re not achieving your goals, it can feel like you’re inherently less valuable.
Social psychology research describes something very similar. Jennifer Crocker and Connie Wolfe (2001) called these contingencies of self-worth: the domains, like achievement, appearance, or others’ approval, where a person’s sense of worth rises with success and drops with setbacks. In a later review, Crocker and Lora Park argued that chasing self-esteem through these domains carries real costs, including to relationships, learning, and wellbeing. And Michael Kernis (2003) drew a distinction between self-esteem that is high but fragile, because it depends on outcomes and approval, and self-esteem that is secure and stable.
Brown’s language is different, but the picture lines up. When self-esteem is linked to your being, you can take on goals, take risks, and even fail, and your sense of value doesn’t collapse with the outcome. Agency gets to become exploration rather than a test you have to pass.
How Ideal Parent Figures Support Self-Esteem
For self-esteem, Brown and Elliott emphasize repeated scenes of the ideal parent figures delighting in both the child’s behavior and the child’s very being, along with support for the child’s sense of competence and mastery. The delight in being comes first.
Here’s one way a scene like this might unfold:
Inside an Ideal Parent Figures Scene
It’s a lazy Sunday morning and you’re about five, still in pajamas, not doing anything special at all. You wander into the room where your ideal parent figures are having coffee, and their whole faces change when they see you. One of them opens their arms and you climb up. “There you are. Our favorite person.” You haven’t drawn anything, won anything, or helped with anything. They’re just so happy you exist. Later that day you try to ride your bike and fall off three times, and they’re right there cheering when you finally make it to the end of the driveway. But the way they looked at you this morning, before you’d done anything, is the thing that stays with you.
Brown and Elliott also describe a separate, self-focused imagery practice for self-esteem that can be used alongside Ideal Parent Figures, moving from moments where you already feel good about yourself toward feeling good simply in your being.
In What Order Do Self-Definition, Self-Agency, and Self-Esteem Develop?
Brown and Elliott present the order as a core sense of self first, then self-definition, then self-agency, then self-esteem, which together support the emergence of what they call the “best self.” They describe each as a layer: a person might have a sense of self but not yet feel effective, or have both a sense of self and agency but still lack self-esteem.
That said, I don’t think of these as strict stair steps, and Brown’s own description shows how intertwined they are. Mastery, which comes from agency, is one of the three sources of self-esteem. And the most important source of self-esteem, delight in your being, starts in infancy, long before a child is making action plans. The ordering is a helpful map of how these qualities build on each other. It’s not a rule that you have to finish one before touching the next. In practice, I tend to see self-esteem as what keeps agency from turning into performance. When the two develop together, going after what you want becomes an expression of who you are rather than a way of proving you deserve to exist. Effort as proof is a big part of why self-improvement doesn’t work as a path to feeling worthy.
The “best self” is Brown’s term for what all of this grows into: a strong, autonomous, and evolving sense of self that can explore the world freely. He’s careful to describe it as something that keeps unfolding across the whole lifespan, not a finished product.
| Quality | Core Question | When It’s Present | When It’s Still Forming | What the Ideal Parent Figures Offer |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-Definition | Who am I? | A stable, familiar sense of “me” across moods, relationships & life stages; your own views and interests | Identity shifts depending on who you’re with; enmeshment; defining yourself from the outside in | Curiosity about who you are, with no agenda for who you should become |
| Self-Agency | Can I make an impact? | Setting goals, making plans & following through; asking for what you need and having it land | Feeling that life happens to you; impulsivity or holding back from acting on plans; needs going unmet in relationships | Reliable responsiveness, collaborative planning & encouragement to affect the world and others |
| Self-Esteem | Do I feel good about who I am? | Warm feeling when you think of yourself; a sense of inherent value you don’t have to earn | Putting others on a pedestal; fear of abandonment; worth that rises and falls with achievement | Delight in your very being, plus support for mastery and competence |
Can You Develop a Strong Sense of Self as an Adult?
Yes. Developing a sense of self in adulthood is very possible. Brown and Elliott’s whole approach rests on the idea that self-development can continue throughout life through the systematic, repeated use of positive imagery. They’re also explicit that interpreting or analyzing gaps in self-development doesn’t tend to help much on its own. In Brown’s words, the absence of a negative state doesn’t necessarily produce the presence of a positive state. What helps is actually experiencing the positive state, over and over, until your system begins to trust it.
The research base for the Ideal Parent Figure method is still small. In a 2017 pilot study by Federico Parra and colleagues, 17 adults with complex PTSD related to childhood trauma took part in a short IPF-based program, and the researchers found significant decreases in symptoms and improvements in quality of life that held at an eight-month follow-up. It was a small study without a control group, so it’s a promising early signal rather than proof. Brown and Elliott’s own pilot study, reported in the book, was also small.
George Haas of Mettagroup, who trained directly with Brown, brings this work together with Buddhist meditation, and one thing I appreciate about his approach is how much it centers people being able to pursue their authentic passions. That’s really where this all leads: not just feeling better about yourself, but living a life that comes from the inside out.
Working With a Coach on Self-Development
In my work with clients at Reparent Yourself, we usually begin with the foundations of secure attachment: safety, being seen, comfort, and delight. As those settle in and a person starts to feel the ideal parent figures as a secure base, the focus naturally widens toward exploration and the development of self. That’s when self-definition, self-agency, and self-esteem come forward.
Every person’s path through this looks different. Some people already have a strong sense of agency and are surprised to find that what they’ve been missing is simply feeling good about who they are when they’re not producing anything. Others have a lovely, rich inner sense of self that they’ve kept hidden, and the work is about letting it be seen. Sessions are recorded so you can return to the meditations between sessions, which gives your system far more time with these new experiences than one hour a week would.
If you’re curious about working together one on one, you can book a discovery call with Reparent Yourself.
Before you go, here’s something you might try. Close your eyes for a moment and evoke your sense of you. What’s there? Is there a felt sense of who you are? What feeling comes along with it? It might feel good, it might feel neutral, it might feel not so good. Whatever you find, that’s useful information, and it can be a starting point for discovering more of who you already are.
Free mini-course
Free Intro to Ideal Parent Figures Course
Reparent Yourself’s free 6-week IPF course gives you an experiential introduction to Ideal Parent Figures, so you can understand what one of the most reliable paths to earned security actually feels like in practice.
Frequently Asked Questions About Self-Definition, Self-Agency, and Self-Esteem
What is the difference between self-esteem and self-agency?
Self-agency is the sense that you can have an impact on the world and on other people, while self-esteem is the positive feeling that comes with your sense of who you are. In Daniel Brown’s model, a person can have strong agency and still lack self-esteem, which often shows up as worth that depends on achievement. Healthy self-esteem is rooted in feeling valued for your being, not only for what you do.
In what order do self-definition, self-agency, and self-esteem develop?
In Attachment Disturbances in Adults, Brown and Elliott describe a core sense of self and self-definition developing first, then self-agency, then self-esteem, which together support the “best self.” The three are closely intertwined, though. Mastery feeds self-esteem, and parental delight, the most important root of self-esteem, begins in infancy.
Why do some high achievers still have low self-esteem?
Brown and Elliott suggest that when a child received warmth mainly for what they did, achievement can become a way of compensating for missing delight in who they are. These people can become very successful but still not feel good about themselves, because accomplishments can’t substitute for feeling valued in one’s being. Research on contingencies of self-worth by Jennifer Crocker describes a similar pattern.
How does anxious attachment affect your sense of self?
People with anxious attachment often learned early on to focus on other people’s states of mind, which can leave less room for developing a clear sense of their own self. Brown and Elliott connect anxious-preoccupied attachment with weaker self-development, and studies have found that attachment anxiety is associated with lower self-concept clarity. This can show up as an identity that shifts depending on the relationship.
How do you build a strong sense of self as an adult?
In Brown and Elliott’s model, building a strong sense of self in adulthood means cultivating self-definition, self-agency, and self-esteem through repeated, positive experiences rather than analyzing what was missing. The Ideal Parent Figure method does this by imagining parent figures who welcome your exploration, support your impact on the world, and delight in who you are. Brown and Elliott also describe separate imagery practices that focus directly on the self.
Dan Lemp is an Ideal Parent Figures facilitator and attachment coach, and the founder of Reparent Yourself. He also runs the Ideal Parent Figures community on Reddit and offers a free six-week introductory course to the method.